Skip to main content
NEU job vacancy
A-levels and U-turns
The secret algorithm that penalised all students — especially those from poorer schools — shows just how little our ruling class actually believes in meritocracy, explain SCIENCE AND SOCIETY

LOOKING into the details of the now-abandoned algorithm used to predict exam results in England last week it was announced that students and teachers had squeezed a hard-fought and rapid U-turn out of the Conservative government.

The reversal of previous decisions in the A-level results fiasco in England followed earlier U-turns by both the SQA under the SNP in Scotland, and the Welsh Labour government.

In an already agonising and difficult year, the government had used an opaque algorithm that was not available for public scrutiny to predict grades for students who were unable to sit their exams due to the coronavirus outbreak.

The word algorithm here is being used to mean the use of statistics to predict and determine outcomes, rather than merely monitor and analyse distributions to better understand them. As in the old saying “lies, damn lies and statistics” — algorithms, or the systematised application of statistics, can be used to justify any political will imaginable.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
A general view of pupils sitting an exam at Lawrence Sheriff school Rugby, Warwickshire
Education / 5 August 2025
5 August 2025
BRAVE NEW WORLD? Annual British Educational Training and Technology conference in London, January 2025, where Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson set out plans to use technology to ‘modernise’ the education system, support teachers and ‘deliver’ for pupils
Technology / 27 June 2025
27 June 2025

NICOLA SARAH HAWKINS explains how an under-regulated introduction of AI into education is already exacerbating inequalities

MORE QUESTIONS THAN ANSWERS: AI Truth Machine / LIT Law Lab,
Features / 12 April 2025
12 April 2025
ANSELM ELDERGILL asks whether artificial intelligence may decide legal cases in the future, in place of human judges, and how AI could reshape the legal landscape