Skip to main content
Wings of hope
MARIA DUARTE recommends a film about two brothers from New Delhi, who have devoted their lives to rescuing the black kites that fall daily from the skies
A scene from All That Breathes

All That Breathes (12A)
Directed by Shaunak Sen

 

 

SET against the backdrop of New Delhi’s toxic air pollution and escalating violence, Indian film-maker Shaunak Sen’s follow-up film to Cities of Sleep explores his home city through a bird called the black kite and two brothers who have devoted their lives to protecting it.

Shot over three years, this captivating documentary follows Nadeem and Saud as they rescue hundreds of these birds, which fall out of the sky daily, treating them in their makeshift bird hospital in their small basement.

Their dream is to build a wildlife rescue centre, initially thwarted when their application for foreign funding is rejected.

Part social and political commentary, part environmental and wildlife study, this is a fascinating yet unconventional documentary which also exams animal-avian and human relationships.

Some of the most touching moments in the film are when the brothers interact with the kites. One involves a staring contest with one of them and another in which they bathe a kite who keeps still and stares fixedly into the distance, either out of sheer enjoyment or abject terror. It’s hard to tell.

The film shows how the two men and their family battle against a broader ecological and social malaise developing around them to save these birds which have been savaged by the toxicity in the air. Plus the rising social tensions, street protests and violence following the government’s controversial Citizenship Act, which discriminates against the 182 million Muslim citizens in India.

The brothers discuss its possible effects on their family in a poignant debate. It is an understated yet complex documentary with flashes of humour and arresting visuals, which slowly reels you in as you begin to understand Nadeem and Saud’s obsession and love of these birds as you will them to fulfil their lifelong goal to open a bird hospital despite all their setbacks.

It provides a whole new perspective on the city and on its wildlife and human populations.

In cinemas

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You can read five articles for free every month,
but please consider supporting us by becoming a subscriber.
More from this author
hallow
Film of the week / 15 May 2025
15 May 2025

MARIA DUARTE is gripped by a tense drama set almost entirely in a car as distressed parents try to rescue their wayward daughter

Treading Water / Pic: IMDb
Film of the week / 24 April 2025
24 April 2025

MARIA DUARTE recommends a tough love story that unfolds among mental health issues, drug addiction and inadequate housing

THE PERILS OF INTERNET DATING: (L) Ruaridh Mollica in Sebast
Cinema / 3 April 2025
3 April 2025
The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews Sebastian, Four Mothers, Restless, and The Most Precious of Cargoes
YOU CAN TAKE THE BOY OUT OF PORT TALBOT, BUT: Toby Jones and
Film of the week / 3 April 2025
3 April 2025
The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE recommends a drama that explores the formative years of Richard Burton’s life
Similar stories
COMPELLING: Radhika Apte in Sister Midnight
Cinema / 13 March 2025
13 March 2025
The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews Last Breath, Sister Midnight, Opus, and The Electric State 
STUNNING: Ethan Herisse and Brandon Turner in Nickel Boys
Cinema / 10 January 2025
10 January 2025
The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews Nickel Boys, Bank of Dave 2: The Loan Ranger, Babygirl, and Maria
Cinema / 7 November 2024
7 November 2024
Lego synaesthesia, a tender portrait of poverty, bear-faced capers and premature Santa: The Star's critic MARIA DUARTE reviews Piece By Piece, Bird, Paddington in Peru and Red One
THE REAL THING: Abdellatif Masstouri and Ayoub Elaid in Houn
Cinema / 13 June 2024
13 June 2024
Posh environmentalism, Moroccan lumpenproletariat, US survivalism and cartoon adolescence