Skip to main content
The Morning Star Shop
Rogan, Kennedy and science: thrills, pills, and big pharma shills
Recent attempts in the US to manufacture controversy around a doctor’s refusal to debate anti-vaxxers tell us more about sophistry than science, write ROX MIDDLETON, LIAM SHAW and JOEL HELLEWELL
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. [Creative Commons / Gage Skidmore]

SCIENCE is a slow process. Evidence accumulates and the scientists working in a particular field learn to live with uncertainties until they can hopefully be removed through future work.

Day to day, most scientists do not ruthlessly question and interrogate the overarching paradigms that structure their work in the background — but that doesn’t mean that widely accepted theories can never be superseded.
 
Challenging widely accepted theories requires not only bravery, since people will initially find your ideas very unlikely, but also patience and a willingness to explain your alternative claims honestly and carefully. However, one thing we must not do is mistake someone’s willingness to argue about their claims with the strength of the actual evidence for what they are saying.
 
Recently, Robert F Kennedy Jr, an outsider Democrat Party presidential candidate (despite his family name and legacy), appeared on the most-listened-to podcast in the world, the Joe Rogan Experience, which attracts around 11 million listeners per episode.

Kennedy claimed that routine vaccinations can cause autism — a claim that almost all medical researchers would reject. Dr Peter Hotez, the dean of the National School of Tropical Medicine at Baylor College of Medicine in Texas, called Kennedy’s comments “misinformation.” Hotez himself previously appeared as a guest on Rogan’s show in April 2020.
 
In response, Rogan, the host of the podcast, offered Hotez $100,000 “to the charity of your choice” if he would debate Kennedy on his show. Hotez refused. From this exchange, many seemed to draw the conclusion that, in being the most willing to debate, Kennedy must have the weight of evidence on his side.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
UNRECOGNISED POTENTIA:L: Girl students conduct an experiment by throwing cotton balls to demonstrate the instinctive reaction of flinching at The Big Bang Fair 2025, for young scientists and engineers, at the NEC in Birmingham on June 18 2025
Science and Society / 16 July 2025
16 July 2025

What’s behind the stubborn gender gap in Stem disciplines ask ROX MIDDLETON, LIAM SHAW and MIRIAM GAUNTLETT in their column Science and Society

The ruins of Guernica after it was bombed by the Nazis on April 26, 1937
Science and Society / 2 July 2025
2 July 2025

While politicians condemned fascist bombing of Spanish civilians in 1937, they ignored identical RAF tactics across the colonies. Today’s aerial warfare continues this pattern of applying different moral standards based on geography and race, write ROX MIDDLETON, LIAM SHAW and MIRIAM GAUNTLETT

LETHAL PLANS: Keir Starmer visits a defence contractor in Bedfordshire
Science and Society / 4 June 2025
4 June 2025

The distinction between domestic and military drones is more theoretical than practical, write ROX MIDDLETON, LIAM SHAW and MIRIAM GAUNTLETT

UNEASY COHABITATION: Southern Ridges, Singapore, 2015 Pic: Zairon/CC
Science and Society / 21 May 2025
21 May 2025

Nature's self-reconstruction is both intriguing and beneficial and as such merits human protection, write ROX MIDDLETON, LIAM SHAW and MIRIAM GAUNTLETT

 

Similar stories
SCIFI
Books / 22 May 2025
22 May 2025

Generous helpings of Hawaiian pidgin, rather good jokes, and dodging the impostors

SCIENCE AND SOCIETY / 22 April 2025
22 April 2025

Science has always been mixed up with money and power, but as a decorative facade for megayachts, it risks leaving reality behind altogether, write ROX MIDDLETON, LIAM SHAW and MIRIAM GAUNTLETT

An electron micrograph of HIV-1 virus particles (colourized
Features / 13 September 2024
13 September 2024
ALAN ROSSI SILVA argues that Gilead’s HIV prevention drug, while promising, highlights systemic failures in the pharmaceutical industry, showing the need to shift towards state-owned drug development and production
FAUSTIAN PACT: Robert Kennedy Jnr shakes hands with Donald t
Features / 26 August 2024
26 August 2024
Robert Kennedy Jnr, in endorsing Donald Trump for president, claims things will be different under his influence and that Trump will ‘honour his word.’ That would be a historic but totally unlikely first, writes LINDA PENTZ GUNTER