Skip to main content
The Crucible, The Yard, London
A relentlessly contemporary interpretation sometimes obscures the underlying intention of Arthur Miller's great play
Stand-out Caoilfhionn Dunne as John Proctor

IT’S no surprise that, for its first ever revival of a classic, the Yard has gone with The Crucible.

Though based on real events in Salem, Massachusetts, at the end of the 17th century, it’s got everything in terms of contemporary relevance — witch-hunts, fake news and fiendish women in a town brought to its knees by rumour and suspicion. So perhaps it’s not such a daring move for anyone hoping to connect with a 2019 audience.

This production certainly goes the extra mile to do so and to underscore the universality, all characters in the programme are listed as a witch. The stage is full of front-facing chairs bearing their names and, as “A note about history” appears on a screen, the cast enter in modern dress to take their seats.

By the time they’ve launched into Miller’s famously exhaustive stage directions, it feels a little like we’re about to sit through three hours of Crucible: The Podcast. There’s an audible sigh of relief when Nina Cassells moves across the stage, prompting not so much a flurry of movement as a glacial slide into some good old-fashioned period drama.

Once the aprons and britches make an appearance, the production springs to life, though the thrill of the story is somewhat punctured by the confusing, yet determined, use of screens and microphones throughout, impelling the actors to work doubly hard to keep up the momentum in what ought to be a pacey and cataclysmic first half.

The production’s conventions are further muddled when, amid the accusations of black magic and witchcraft, masked demons appear on stage dressed in black hoodies, with their bald plastic faces reminiscent of a freakish Instagram filter.

Visually, it’s a treat and presumably these spectres are supposed to represent a kind of modern evil running rife amid the poppets and needles.

But the point feels somewhat laboured, undermining the very human tragedy of the tale. While it makes sense to weave a 2019 angle into this battle over truth and lies, director Jay Miller’s devices ultimately don’t improve on Miller’s original metaphor pointing up the political witch-hunts of the McCarthy era in the US.

Insta-demons aside, there’s much that makes a long evening in the world’s most uncomfortable seating worthwhile. When the actors are left alone to act, they deliver. Lucy Vandi is wonderful as Tituba, while Sophie Duval’s comic charm brings a Brechtian swagger to all her characterisations.

Emma D’Arcy’s performance as Elizabeth Proctor is electrifying, and, unsurprisingly, Caoilfhionn Dunne delivers a stand-out performance as John Proctor.

Between the two of them the play finds its mark and it eventually becomes clear that beneath the bells and whistles, there’s an incendiary magic to be found in this Crucible.

Runs until May 11, box office: theyardtheatre.co.uk

Morning Star Conference - Race, Sex & Class
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Culture / 11 November 2020
11 November 2020
Ruby Fischer hails a photobook that celebrates the freedom, delight and mischief of childhood among Travellers
ONLINE WATCH / 13 April 2020
13 April 2020
Timely celebration of women's global contribution to the art and craft of of film-making
(Left to right) Power figure (nkisi), Kongo peoples (Loango,
Picture This / 12 February 2020
12 February 2020
Revelatory exploration of funerary practice in sub-Saharan Africa
Left to right- The empty window+Franziska Goes to Heaven+Ama
Exhibition / 13 November 2019
13 November 2019
RUBY FISCHER sees a potent exhibition of the enigmatic and troubling paintings produced by Charlotte Salomon before she was consigned to a nazi death camp
Similar stories
The referee spots the pink ball on day fourteen of the 2024
Snooker / 11 April 2025
11 April 2025
As the 2025 World Snooker Championship looms, the road to Sheffield is already alive with drama, from teenage prodigies to legendary veterans, writes JAMES NALTON
INTERROGATING THE SEX WORKER: Will Bliss (Abberline) and Ste
Theatre review / 25 October 2024
25 October 2024
JAN WOOLF marvels at a rich brew of steam-punk Victoriana, homosexual scandal, and contemporary reference
Jasmine Blackorow (Miss Bauer) and Michael Aloni (Art) in Da
Theatre Review / 26 September 2024
26 September 2024
MARY CONWAY feels the contemporary resonance of a new play set amid the manic and self-destructive patriotism of the McCarthy era
NAZIDAMMERUNG: Marion Cotillard in Lee
Film of the Week: / 12 September 2024
12 September 2024
MARIA DUARTE recommends the story of surrealist turned photojournalist Lee Miller