Skip to main content
‘Holding voices together in common cause’
FRAN LOCK recommends a poetry anthology that spotlights our varied experiences under the multiple oppressions of global capitalism
(L to R) Istvan Vas, Kathleen Kenny and Anna Greki

Smokestack Lightning
edited by Andy Croft
Smokestack Books £9.99

AT A RECENT event celebrating the launch of Culture Matters’s The Cry of the Poor: An Anthology of Radical Writing About Poverty (2021) I got chatting to one of our contributors about the perils and the pleasures of the anthology form. He suggested that a large number of contemporary anthologies fail — as both literature and politics — because the claims they make for themselves are so grossly exaggerated, or because their organising conceit is artificial and painfully forced. Or both. I tend to agree.

At their worst, anthologies can be prone to the kinds of essentialising value judgement that implicitly exclude the many poetic voices who do not conform to the narrow prescriptive dictates of “house style,” or else are not comfortably cradled within the arbitrary limits of this or that definition.

What counts, for example, as radical or as innovative writing? Who gets to decide who qualifies as working class? As neurodiverse? As British? As queer? Who polices the borders of all our classed, gendered, and otherwise vexed categories of belonging?

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
boix
Literature / 22 June 2026
22 June 2026

From post-human revolution in Puerto Rico to trans poetics and queer mythmaking, these three books that imagine new ways of being together

shoulder
Poetry Review / 1 May 2026
1 May 2026

Read this book and be aware that this is our history, says RUTH AYLETT

cover
Poetry / 26 November 2025
26 November 2025

RUTH AYLETT reviews two collections of outright political poetry

sausages
Books / 18 July 2025
18 July 2025

ANDY CROFT rallies poets to the impossible task of speaking truth to a tin-eared politician