Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
Without fundamental change the politics of despair will only grow

Our economic system is broken – and unless we break with the government’s obsession with short-termist private profit, things are destined to get worse, warns Mercedes Villalba

People taking part in a ‘Tommy Robinson’-led Unite the Kingdom march and rally in central London ,September 13, 2025

WE ALL know the deal. It wasn’t made by us, but we uphold our end, nonetheless. Those who can, work and in exchange we all benefit from each other’s labour and are the better for it. For a time that seemed to bear fruit. Our grandparents lived longer than their grandparents, and our parents had more choice than their parents, yet the current bargain is leaving our potential rotting on the vine.

British life expectancy progress has reportedly stalled. But the retirement age continues to rise. Much of our lives will continue to be spent in labour.

Workers have suffered stagnant or falling wages since 2008, yet the cost of housing, food and energy have reached record highs leaving little, if anything, left at the end of the month.

Today, we’re working to live and living to work.

One in four adults in England will experience a mental health problem this year while 30 per cent of the UK population live with one or more such long-term conditions, robbing us of the freedom to enjoy what time we do have outside of work.

So, yes, we are working, but we are not feeling the benefit, and it’s no surprise that we are asking, in increasing numbers: what are we working for?

In fact, as Morning Star readers know, under the current economic system, we are largely working for private profit. Whether through the labour we exchange for currency or the currency we exchange for goods and services, at every opportunity profit is extracted and, through the global economic system, pools among an ever more concentrated elite.
But that is not what we’re told by those in power.

We’re told that either “you’re poorer because your neighbour is taking more than their fair share” or “you’re poorer because the people you elected to manage things previously did a bad job.”

These are red herrings which, though struggled to gain traction for a time, are now being heard by a much wider audience.

The latter is proving especially unconvincing from a Prime Minister who is seen as “untrustworthy” and a British government which swathes of the public think is handling many key issues badly. So, without a credible alternative, the former is taking root.

People do not simply give up, it’s not in our nature. And what we saw this weekend in London, and what we are seeing across the country outside asylum detention centres, is the result of people having been squeezed too tight for too long.

It’s not too late to counteract this sentiment, but to do so we must put forward a persuasive vision for change — and deliver it.

It’s not complicated. Every person alive requires the same fundamentals to survive: air, water, food and shelter. Fortunately, these necessities, or the resources required to create them, are all naturally occurring — given by the earth freely so long as we nurture its environment.

Yet as a species we have allowed the profit motive to dominate our environment, withdrawing these necessities ever further from our reach, until we are utterly dependent on this intermediary system choking our supply to these life-giving ingredients.

Doctors say UK air pollution is killing more than 500 people a week. According to the Trussell Trust more than 14.1 million people in the UK faced hunger in the past year. Serious water pollution incidents are up 60 per cent, according to the government’s Environment Agency, and homelessness is on the rise all around the UK, with one in every 200 households experiencing it.

And we are not alone in this. Globally, an estimated seven million are killed by air pollution each year, 300 hundred million are at risk of death from starvation, 1.8 billion are facing absolute water scarcity, and more than 1.8 billion people worldwide lack adequate housing.

Clearly, any vision of change must take an internationalist perspective and seek to tackle the system, which for too long has been allowed to put short-term profit before human life.

Without this systemic change no amount of admirable local changes will be enough. Yes, the British Labour government is recruiting GPs and teachers, bringing rail into public ownership, and ending zero-hours contracts — as a people’s government should. But it has also cut benefits, rejected a wealth tax and armed a genocide, delivering not for workers, but the bosses who pick their pockets. We need an urgent alternative.

A tax on wealth to show a statement of intent. A relentlessness drive to democratise our economy and close the inequality gap. And, most of all, a vision. Of hope, to rally, to reassure and to reunite our communities.

The alternative is the far right. We saw that this weekend.

The number of the discontented is swelling. And it will only grow.

We ignore them at our peril.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Prime Minister Keir Starmer delivers a speech at the Government's first Civil Society Summit in London, July 17, 2025
Features / 26 July 2025
26 July 2025

The shock suspension of socialist MPs and Diane Abbott’s re-suspension reveals a leadership intent on crushing internal debate  —  but MERCEDES VILLALBA MSP warns against surrendering party democracy without a fight

Voices of Scotland / 12 July 2023
12 July 2023
Attempts to mystify the workings of the economy in a neoliberal smog are failing — the British public is calling out for an interventionist approach under direct state control, writes MERCEDES VILLALBA MSP
CONTROVERSY: An aerial view of the Scottish Parliament
at H
Features / 19 January 2023
19 January 2023
The Westminster government’s decision to invoke Section 35 over the gender recognition reform Bill on trans rights is a cynical attack on the principle of devolution, argues MERCEDES VILLALBA MSP
VOICES OF SCOTLAND / 9 January 2023
9 January 2023
MERCEDES VILLALBA MSP looks at the Scottish government’s proposed Land Reform Act and argues that it fails to properly address this entrenched inequality that is obstructing housing and environmental reform
Similar stories
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer listens to a question from the press, after making a statement in Downing Street, London, July 29, 2025
Neoliberalism / 31 July 2025
31 July 2025

Deep disillusionment with the Westminster cross-party consensus means rupture with the status quo is on the cards – bringing not only opportunities but also dangers, says NICK WRIGHT

Various For Sale, Sold and Let By estate agent signs juxtaposed next to a Dreams store in Clapham, London
Class / 18 July 2025
18 July 2025

Our housing crisis isn’t an accident – it’s class war, trapping millions in poverty while landlords and billionaires profit. To solve it, we need comprehensive transformation, not mere tokenistic reform, writes BECK ROBERTSON

WAY FORWARD: People's Assembly Against Austerity protest in central London on June 7 2025
Politics / 11 July 2025
11 July 2025

RICHARD BURGON MP points to the recent relative success of widespread opposition to the Labour leadership’s regressive policies as the blueprint for exacting the changes required to build a fairer society

UNITED WE STAND: A lantern parade in Liverpool marks the reopening of Spellow Community Hub and Library after it was torched during riots in August 2024
Politics / 16 May 2025
16 May 2025

BILL GREENSHIELDS urges an intensification of the information offensive against the impact of the spurious discourse peddled by Reform UK