Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
University closures would be a ‘tragedy’, warns Edinburgh axeman
A general view of the University of Edinburgh Old College, Edinburgh

THE architect of £140 million of cuts at Edinburgh University has warned it would be a “tragedy” if the sector’s funding crisis led to closures.

Speaking to BBC Scotland, the institution’s £418,000-a-year vice-principal, Sir Peter Mathieson, who plans slash jobs to make cuts equivalent to 10 per cent of its turnover, has called for a rethink of university funding in Scotland.

The Edinburgh vice-principal argued the £7,500 fee received for Scottish students was below cost, forcing universities to become reliant on overseas students for income.

His own institution raked in £360m from foreign students, compared with just £27m in fees from Scottish counterparts. 

That reliance has, however, plunged the sector into crisis as numbers plummeted in recent years.

Calling for the SNP’s totemic free tuition policy to be reconsidered, Sir Peter said: “We need more income into the system, either through some kind of means testing or a postgraduate system of earnings repayment.

“Either we have tuition fees which are adequate to pay the costs, or we have another mechanism to pay the costs.

“If we had a hybrid system, where some people pay fees and some people don’t, one possibility is that that’s means-tested in some way.

“If it’s to be a political priority, then it has to be adequately funded to ensure its future,” he added.

Referring to Dundee University’s £35m deficit crisis, where as many as 700 — or 20 per cent — of its workforce face redundancy, he said: “It would be a tragedy for Scotland if other universities were to get themselves into a similar situation.”

But his own cuts programme has been branded “academic vandalism” by UCU general secretary Jo Grady.

The Scottish government has been approached for comment.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Anti-fascist protesters in Aberdeen
Climate Crisis / 25 July 2025
25 July 2025
US military aircraft fly over Torry Battery at the entrance to Aberdeen Harbour, ahead of US President Donald Trump's visit to his golf courses in golf courses in Aberdeenshire and Ayrshire, July 22, 2025
Antifascism / 24 July 2025
24 July 2025

Campaigners promise to welcome the US president to Scotland with a ‘festival of resistance’

Similar stories
A general view of the University of Edinburgh Old College, E
Britain / 6 April 2025
6 April 2025
University graduates
Britain / 16 March 2025
16 March 2025
University of Edinburgh
Britain / 26 February 2025
26 February 2025