Skip to main content

Error message

An error occurred while searching, try again later.
Gifts from The Morning Star
Starmer faces defeat over benefits cuts as more than 100 Labour MPs rebel

Disability charity Sense applauds rebel MPs for ‘pushing back against this unjust policy’

Protesters on Whitehall in London, as Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves delivers her spring statement to MPs in the House of Commons, London, March 26, 2025

PRIME Minister Sir Keir Starmer was facing defeat in his plan to slash benefits for disabled people after more than 100 Labour MPs backed an amendment to ditch the plans.

If the Tories decide to back the move, and the amendment is put to a vote when the Welfare Bill is debated next week, this would be enough to inflict a humiliating defeat on the government.

The MPs include a large number of normally loyal Starmer supporters, indicating the depth of political disquiet over the £5 billion cuts.

After U-turning on the cuts to winter fuel benefit, a further climbdown would fatally compromise the government’s credibility. 

However, many voices across the labour movement were demanding that Sir Keir abandon the cuts.

But the Prime Minister was doubling down today, telling the Cabinet that the welfare “system is currently failing people, trapping millions, telling them the only way to get help is to declare they will never work again, and then abandoning them without hope and opportunity.”

He later denied that the cuts were funding the enormous increases in arms spending he signed up to at the Nato summit in the Netherlands.

Sir Keir claimed: “It’s a misdescription to suggest that the defence spending commitment we’ve made is at the expense of money on welfare.

“We’ve made a huge commitment to the money we’re putting in to get people back to work.

“The welfare system is broken and that’s why we will press ahead with our reforms.”

He added that there was “a clear moral case” for the cuts. 

However, many MPs say they have found heavy-handed lobbying by Sir Keir and Chancellor Rachel Reeves counter-productive.

The rebel amendment instructs the Commons to cease progress on the Bill “because the government’s own impact assessment estimates that 250,000 people will be pushed into poverty as a result of these provisions, including 50,000 children.”

The MPs add that there has been no consultation with disabled people about the changes, and that the impact assessment from the Office for Budget Responsibility will not be published until the autumn.

Among the 108 MPs signing the amendment are 10 chairs of powerful Commons committees, including Meg Hillier of the Treasury committee and Debbie Abrahams of the work and pensions committee.

Ms Hillier said: “We don’t disagree that there is a need to reform welfare but it’s hard to deliver the proposed improvements in the proposed timescale. And disabled people must be protected.”

Vicky Foxcroft, the Labour whip who resigned over the cuts, has also signed.

Commons Speaker Lindsay Hoyle would need to select the amendment when MPs debate the legislation on July 1. Other amendments to block the Bill have been tabled by independent MPs and smaller parties.

The Tories, torn between their bedrock commitment to attacking the poor and the opportunity to embarrass the government, have not yet indicated how they will vote.

Transport union TSSA general secretary Maryam Eslamdoust said: “It’s vital that ministers pause and reconsider what they are trying to achieve with these welfare cuts which will only hurt those most in need across our society.

“Many MPs are clearly doing the right thing by challenging such injurious plans — they have listened to the many voices of disabled groups and charities.”

And Fire Brigades Union general secretary Steve Wright said: “It’s outrageous that the government is ploughing on regardless with welfare cuts in the face of such huge opposition among Labour MPs and the party as a whole. 

“It’s possible that Keir Starmer will be dependent on the Commons votes of Tory MPs to pass this new wave of austerity for the most vulnerable. 

“That’s a shameful thing for any Labour prime minister to do.”

James Watson-O’Neill, chief executive of the national disability charity Sense, said: “The government’s proposed welfare reforms would be devastating for disabled people, and we applaud the MPs pushing back against this unjust policy.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Former Labour Party leader, Jeremy Corbyn M.P. (left) and Zarah Sultana, MP for Coventry South on the picket line outside London Euston train station. Picture date: Thursday August 18, 2022
Parliamentary Politics / 24 July 2025
24 July 2025

Corbyn and Sultana commit to launching new socialist party

Former home secretary James Cleverly delivers a speech at The Institute for Public Policy (IPPR) in London, July 15, 2025
Tory Party / 22 July 2025
22 July 2025
Prime Minister Keir Starmer delivers a speech at the Government's first Civil Society Summit in London, July 17, 2025
Eyes Left / 23 July 2025
23 July 2025

If Labour MPs who rebelled over the welfare reforms expected to be listened to, they shouldn’t have underestimated the vindictiveness of the Starmer regime. But a new left party that might rehome them is yet to be established, writes ANDREW MURRAY
 

Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer delivers a speech at the government's first Civil Society Summit in London, which aims to bring together leaders from charities, expert groups, communities, and government, July 17, 2025
Britain / 17 July 2025
17 July 2025

Starmer doubles down on witch hunt by suspending the whip from Diane Abbott