Skip to main content
Making music in the USSR

JONATHAN TAYLOR is intrigued by an account of the struggle of Soviet-era musicians to adapt to the strictures of social realism

Dmitri Shostakovich voting in the election of the Council of Administration of Soviet Musicians in Moscow in 1974 / Pic: Yuri Shcherbinin/CC

The Sound of Utopia: Musicians in the Time of Stalin
Michel Krielaars, Pushkin Press, £25



In 1948, Dmitri Shostakovich, Sergei Prokofiev, Aram Khachaturian and other prominent Soviet composers were attacked by Andrei Zhdanov, Joseph Stalin’s culture secretary. He accused them of “bourgeois formalism,” and demanded in its place “socialist realism” – an optimistic, conservative, accessible music for the people. The row was the culmination of years of friction between the regime and its composers – most famously, Shostakovich.

This is the backdrop to Michel Krielaars’s fascinating new book, The Sound of Utopia, which describes the fate of various classical and popular musicians during Stalin’s reign. They include the composers Sergei Prokofiev, Alexander Mossolov, Mieczyslaw Weinberg and Tikhon Khrennikov, the pianists Sviastoslav Richter and Maria Yudina, the popular singers Klavdiya Shulzhenko and Vadim Kozim, and the cellist Mstislav Rostropovich.

All of them fell foul of the authorities for one reason or another: Kozim because of his homosexuality, Weinberg because of his Jewishness, Yudina because of her outspoken religiosity, Khrennikov because of his dubious position as general secretary of the Composers’ Union, Rostropovich owing to his courageous defence of others.

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Features / 11 November 2024
11 November 2024
At the start of National Anti-Bullying Week, JONATHAN TAYLOR explains that recognising the signs of bullying is the first step towards being able to do something about it
NAZI ASPIRATIONS: Wilhelm Furtwangler conducting the Berlin
Book Review / 15 February 2024
15 February 2024
JONATHAN TAYLOR excavates the paradox that underlies Burgess’s ambivalent attitude to music
Similar stories
The performance
Culture / 30 December 2024
30 December 2024
BEN LUNN highly recommends a cantata that encapsulates the Palestinian peoples' profound desire for peace
Music / 30 September 2024
30 September 2024
New releases from The The, Memo Comma and Anna Gourari/Orchestra della Svizzera italiana 
BROTHERS IN ARMS: Soviet and Polish resistance Armia Krajowa
Books / 2 August 2024
2 August 2024
WILL PODMORE welcomes, with reservations, a new history of Operation Bagration and the Red Army’s defeat of Nazi Germany
WE LOVE THE RED SOCKS SONNYBOY: LSO, conducted by Gianandrea
Concert review / 2 July 2024
2 July 2024
SIMON DUFF is thrilled by the provocative pairing of two major works from a time of profound ideological opposition