Skip to main content
NEU job vacancy
How we dodged the mushroom cloud in 2024
MATTHEW ALFORD considers the principal four reasons there wasn’t a nuclear exchange this year, despite the Ukraine war, the carnage in the Middle East, the provocations over Taiwan — and his best predictions

I MADE a bet in January this year that I’d clean my horrible stairs if humanity didn’t nuke itself by New Year’s 2025, and throughout the year, I remained pretty confident I’d never have to deliver. But it looks like I’m breaking out Henry Hoover.
 
How did it all go so wrong for my never-cleaning plan? In a year of catastrophic violence on the borders of Russia and across the Middle East, how have we escaped the terminus that is the mushroom cloud? There are four main reasons.
 
Firstly, the relative restraint of Iran, Russia and China. We can quibble about Russia, which has been the most aggressive of the three. For sure, Iran, though, has had casus belli to hit Israel fatally but has opted instead for demonstration strikes.

China, for its part, has not been drawn into a much-anticipated fight on the Taiwan Straits or in the South China Sea. These are perhaps the most serious flashpoints in the world — because if China did mobilise, the US wouldn’t be able to do much except slink away or threaten to use nukes.
 
Second: no stupid accidents. Battlefield mistakes happen with alarming frequency, and we’re due one any day. Memorably, due to a silly mix-up, Russia nearly blew up 30 RAF personnel in 2022. They would have done so had the airman’s missile not miraculously jammed in its bay. If such a fatality occurs, we will be lethally engaged with Russia.
 
Third: Donald Trump won the election. Many of Trump’s colleagues are hawks, but he has an instinct for moderation in foreign policy. It’s hard to know how important Trump himself has been to our survival these past few weeks, but his presence may have been crucial.

For instance, on December 11, Ukraine fired six US Atacms against an airbase outside the Russian city of Taganrog. Russian authorities immediately signalled that they were preparing to respond with several Oreshnik missiles — Moscow’s lightning-speed new missile system that can carry a nuclear payload.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
President Donald Trump meet with Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy in the Oval Office at the White House, August 18, 2025, in Washington
Features / 22 August 2025
22 August 2025

Washington plays innocent bystander while pouring weapons and intelligence into Ukraine, just as it enables the Gaza genocide — but every US escalation leaves Ukraine weaker than the neutrality deal rejected in 2022, argue MEDEA BENJAMIN and NICOLAS JS DAVIES

Orkney
Music Festival / 28 May 2025
28 May 2025

ANGUS REID recommends a visit to an outstanding gathering of national and international folk musicians in the northern archipelago

United States Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth speaks durin
Opinion / 18 February 2025
18 February 2025
By honestly telling Ukraine that it will not become a Nato member, Trump and Hegseth have opened the door to a possible end to the conflict but have also altered the political dynamic on both sides of the Atlantic, write MEDEA BENJAMIN and NICOLAS JS DAVIES
STANDING FIRM: CND activists protest at RAF Lakenheath again
Features / 24 December 2024
24 December 2024
Speaking to Ben Chacko, CND’s new leader SOPHIE BOLT outlines her organisation’s ambitious plans, from peace camps to base blockades to mass mobilisation, to fight the rising nuclear madness our politicians ignore