Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
The good the bad and the ugly
DENNIS BROE counsels ideological caution when committing to the next batch of ‘series’ visited on us by the predatory networks this autumn
HONOURABLE: Thierry Godard as Toussaint Maheu in Germinal [SALTO]

IT’S Emmy Award season but rather than dwell on television’s past it might be better to dwell on its future.

What follows are the best (and worst) of autumn series previewed at the recently concluded Series Mania, the Festival of Global Television in the French north-west former mining centre of Lille, where many of the series were concerned with either highlighting or concealing and smoothing over class differences in the wake of the vast transfer of wealth that has followed the Covid billionaire accumulation in the online goldrush.
 
The location was relevant because the best of these series was a new French public television version of Germinal. Two episodes of the six were broadcast at sites throughout this region which, when Zola wrote the novel in the 1880s about a coalminers’ action in 1860, was still the coalmining and industrial centre of the world.

The novel is a long debate about the need for, the effectiveness of, and the tactical ways of managing a strike as a way of workers clawing back some measure of decency from a life which requires ever more sacrifices just to make one’s daily bread.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
nauti nauti
Decoding Network TV / 29 July 2025
29 July 2025

DENNIS BROE enjoys the political edge of a series that unmasks British imperialism, resonates with the present and has been buried by Disney

LONGSTANDING MILITARY TIES: (L) Leo Woodall as ‘sexy mathe
Decoding network TV / 24 March 2025
24 March 2025
DENNIS BROE points out that Apple is part of the corporate and state surveillance network which the new series Prime Target rails against
BARE-KNUCKLE: Stephen Graham and Malachi Kirby in A Thousand
TV Series review / 4 March 2025
4 March 2025
DENNIS BROE appreciates the work of TV writer Steven Knight, and his systematic exposure of the debilitating effects of British capitalism
(L) Toby Jones as Alan Bates in Mr Bates Vs The Post Office;
Best of 2024 / 10 December 2024
10 December 2024
DENNIS BROE picks his highlights
Similar stories
marked
Decoding Network TV / 12 August 2025
12 August 2025

DENNIS BROE finds much to praise in the new South African Netflix series, but wonders why it feels forced to sell out its heroine

Amanda Seyfried and Rivera Reese in Long Bright River (2025)
TV Network Monitor / 22 April 2025
22 April 2025

DENNIS BROE sifts out the ideological bias of the newest TV series offerings, and picks out what to see, and what to avoid

MISLEADING: Owen Cooper and Stephen Graham in Adolescence
Decoding Network TV / 4 April 2025
4 April 2025
DENNIS BROE doubts the virtue of showing this series in schools, given its damaging portrayal of working-class boys as irredeemably violent
BARE-KNUCKLE: Stephen Graham and Malachi Kirby in A Thousand
TV Series review / 4 March 2025
4 March 2025
DENNIS BROE appreciates the work of TV writer Steven Knight, and his systematic exposure of the debilitating effects of British capitalism