Skip to main content
Regional secretary with the National Education Union
Best of intentions pave way to indifference
MARY CONWAY is disappointed to see a once award-winning comedy lose its spark entirely
ZERO INTERACTION: Lucy Black (Teresa), Laura Rogers (Mary) and Carolina Main (Catherine) [Helen Murray]

The Memory of Water
Hampstead Theatre
★★

SHELAGH STEPHENSON’S The Memory of Water at Hampstead Theatre is a prime example of how time changes everything.

In the year 2000, this play won an Olivier Award for best new comedy and was subsequently adapted for a film (Before You Go) starring Julie Walters. Now it seems less notable for its crowd-pleasing content than for a creaky storyline, laboured attempts at comedy and a range of under-developed and almost indistinguishable characters.

Not that I blame artistic director, Roxana Silbert, for selecting it. It must have seemed like a safe revival at a time when current themes are so dispiriting. But the result, despite huge commitment from director Alice Hamilton, cast and crew, is a listless affair, addressing too many inconclusive themes while seeming to grab at arbitrary cultural references that never take us to moments of genuine insight.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
stars
Theatre review / 14 July 2025
14 July 2025

MARY CONWAY applauds the success of Beth Steel’s bitter-sweet state-of-the-nation play

intimate
Theatre review / 30 June 2025
30 June 2025

MARY CONWAY is blown away by a flawless production of Lynn Nottage’s exquisite tragedy

moon
Theatre review / 27 June 2025
27 June 2025

MARY CONWAY revels in the Irish American language and dense melancholy of O’Neill’s last and little-known play

NUANCED AND COMMANDING: Bessie Carter as Vivie Warren) and Imelda Staunton as Mrs Kitty Warren / Pic: Johan Persson
Theatre review / 25 May 2025
25 May 2025

MARY CONWAY recommends a play that some will find more discursive than eventful but one in which the characters glow

Similar stories
deal
Theatre review / 14 May 2025
14 May 2025

In this production of David Mamet’s play, MARY CONWAY misses the essence of cruelty that is at the heart of the American deal

UN-NUANCED: Sophie Melville, Leander Deeny, Laura Whitmore i
Theatre Review / 6 April 2025
6 April 2025
MARY CONWAY is disappointed by characters so un-nuanced as to be unreal, a stereotypical plot and a conceptual vampire
Nigel Betts (Billy) and Nigel Cooke (Cliff) in Double Act
Theatre review / 29 January 2025
29 January 2025
MARY CONWAY applauds a study of comedians in whose cheap prejudice the tenets of the emerging political right are crystal clear
(L) Playwright Richard Bean; (R) John Hollingworth as Donald
Interview / 5 November 2024
5 November 2024
MAYER WAKEFIELD speaks to playwright Richard Bean about his new play Reykjavik that depicts the exploitation of the Hull-based “far-fleet” trawlermen